What’s best to eat for recovery after a hard workout? That’s what marathoners, body builders, and fitness exercisers alike repeatedly ask. They read ads for commercial recovery foods that demand a 3 to 1 ratio of carbs to protein, tout the benefits of a proprietary formula, or emphasize immediate consumption the minute you stop exercising. While these ads offer an element of truth, consumers beware: Engineered recovery foods are not more effective than standard foods. The purpose of this article is to educate you, a hungry athlete, about how to choose an optimal recovery diet.
Too many athletes are obsessed with rapidly refueling the minute they stop exercising. They are afraid they will miss the one-hour “window of opportunity” when glycogen replacement is fastest. They fail to understand refueling still occurs for several hours, just at a slowing rate.
Engineered Recovery Foods Are
Not More Effective Than Standard Foods
Given a steady influx of adequate carb-based meals and snacks, muscles can refuel within 24 hours. If you have a full day to recover before your next training session, or if you have done an easy (non-depleting) workout, you need not obsess about refueling immediately afterwards.
Refueling as soon as tolerable is most important for serious athletes doing a second bout of intense, depleting exercise within six hours of the first workout, including triathletes doing double workouts, soccer players in tournaments and people who ski hard in the morning and again in the afternoon.
The sooner you consume carbs to replace depleted muscle glycogen and protein to repair damaged muscle, the sooner you’ll be able to exercise hard again.
Over the course of the next 24 hours your muscles will have lots of time to replenish glycogen stores. Just be sure to repeatedly consume a foundation of carbohydrates with each meal/snack, along with some protein to build and repair the muscles. For example, chocolate milk or a fruit smoothie are excellent choices.
How many carbs do you need? According to the International Olympic Committee’s Nutrition Recommendations, adequate carbs means:
For moderate exercise:
About 1 hour/day = 2.5 to 3 grams carb/lb or 5 to 7 grams carb/kg
For endurance exercise:
1 to 3 hours/day = 2.5 to 4.5 grams carb/lb or 6 to 10 grams carb/kg
For extreme exercise:
Greater than 4 to 5 hours/day = 3.5 to 5.5 grams carb/lb or 8 to 12 grams carb/kg
Example: a 150-lb triathlete doing extreme exercise should target about 500 to 800 grams carb/day (2,000-3,200 carb-calories).
Your recovery meals and snacks should include a foundation of carbohydrate-rich breads, cereals, grains, fruits, and vegetables plus a smaller amount of protein (at least 10-20 grams per recovery snack or meal). You can enjoy fruit smoothies (Greek yogurt + banana + berries), cereal + milk, bagel + latté (decaf), pretzels + hummus, baked potato + cottage cheese, turkey sub, or pasta + meatballs.
Do NOT consume only protein, as in a protein shake or protein bar. Protein fills your stomach and helps build and repair muscles, but it does not refuel your muscles. Your muscles want three or four times more calories from carbs than from protein. If you like the convenience of protein shakes, at least add some carbs to them. That is, blend in some banana, frozen berries, and graham crackers.
Keep in mind that recovery calories count. I hear many frustrated dieters complain they are not losing weight despite hard workouts. Perhaps that’s because they gobble 300 or so “recovery calories” and then go home and enjoy a hefty dinner. By organizing your training to end at mealtime, you can avoid over-indulging in recovery-calories.
What about recovery electrolytes? After a hard workout, many athletes reach for a sports drink, thinking Gatorade or PowerAde is “loaded” with sodium (an electrically charged particle). Think again! Milk and other “real foods” are actually better sources of electrolytes than most commercial sports products. These electrolytes (also known as sodium and potassium) help enhance fluid retention and the restoration of normal fluid balance. Here’s how some common recovery fluids compare:
Beverage (8 oz):
Water = 0 Sodium (mg), 0 Potassium (mg), 0 Protein (g), 0 Carbs (g)
PowerAde = 55 Sodium (mg), 45 Potassium (mg), 0 Protein (g), 19 Carbs (g)
Gatorade = 110 Sodium (mg), 30 Potassium (mg), 0 Protein (g), 14 Carbs (g)
Low-fat milk = 100 Sodium (mg), 400 Potassium (mg), 8 Protein (g), 12 Carbs (g)
Chocolate milk = 150 Sodium (mg), 425 Potassium (mg), 8 Protein (g), 26 Carbs
Orange juice = 0 Sodium (mg), 450 Potassium (mg), 2 Protein (g), 26 Carbs (g)
After a hard workout, recovery fluids such as chocolate milk, orange juice, or a latte offer far more “good stuff” than you’d get in a sports drink. Sports drinks are dilute and designed for during extended exercise.
To assess how much sodium you lose in sweat, weigh yourself naked pre-post an hour of exercise, accounting for any fluid consumed. Loss of one pound equates to loss of about 700 to 1,000 mg sodium. If you sweat heavily and lose a significant amount of sodium, you can easily replace those losses with pretzels (300 mg sodium/10 twists), a bagel (500 mg) with peanut butter (200 mg/2 tbsp), Wheaties and milk (300 mg), or a spaghetti dinner with tomato sauce (1000 mg/cup Ragu sauce). Most athletes consume plenty of sodium!
Your recovery can start before you exercise. What you eat before you exercise impacts your recovery. According to research presented at the 2011 annual meeting of the American College of Sports Medicine, consuming protein before lifting weights enhances recovery better than consuming a protein drink afterwards. That’s because your body digests pre-exercise protein into amino acids (yes, your body can digest food during exercise) and puts those amino acids right into action repairing damaged muscles.
What if you feel like you never really recover well? If you have to drag yourself through workouts, a number of questions arise: Are you overtraining? Rest is an essential part of a training program; muscles need time to refuel and repair. Take at least one if not two days off from exercise per week.
Are you anemic? Anemia is common, so have your MD monitor your serum ferritin (stored iron). If your iron stores are depleted, you’ll feel needlessly tired during exercise. An estimated half of female athletes are iron-deficient, as indicated by low serum ferritin stores. (About 14 percent of all women are iron deficient.) A survey with collegiate male runners suggested about 20 percent had low serum ferritin. Iron supplements can help resolve the problem, alongside a good recovery diet. Eat wisely, recover well, and feel great!
Nancy Clark, MS, RD, CSSD (Board Certified Specialist in Sports Dietetics) counsels both casual and competitive athletes at her office in Newton, MA (617-795-1875). Her best-selling Sports Nutrition Guidebook and food guides for new runners, marathoners, and soccer players offer additional information. They are available at www.nancyclarkrd.com. See also www.sportsnutritionworkshop.com.
Nutrition for Athletes: A practical guide to eating for health and performance. Prepared by the Nutrition Working Group of the International Olympic Committee, Feb. 2010; http://www.thecgf.com/media/games/2010/CGF_Nutrition.pdf
Campos, Manuel, S. Gervais, J. Walker, A. Olson. Iron deficiency in Division III male cross country and track runners. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2010; 42(5 Supplement): Abstract 2821
Lee, Choi Hyun, J. Kim, K. Hoon Park, J. Lee. Effect of the timing of protein supplement on recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2010; 42(5 Supplement): Abstract 2862.
Nicewonger, Christine, J. Flohr, M. Todd, C. Womack. The effect of iron supplementation on iron markers and performance in female athletes. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2010; 42(5 Supplement): Abstract 2822
The articles written by guest contributors are the sole responsibility of the individual writers in terms of factual accuracy and opinion and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher of this blog.